More from Radio Exe




Councillors want convincing over viability concerns at troubled homes site
By
Alison Stephenson (Local democracy reporter)
Friday, 30 October 2026
16:44

Unfinished homes in the Lipson development site. Picture: submitted
Wait continues over Plymouth housing plans
Developers will have to wait a bit longer to know if Plymouth planners are prepared to let them drop 44 affordable homes from a scheme at Lipson.
Lipson Developments Ltd claim it is not viable to build the units on former allotment gardens at Prince Maurice Road, where there is planning permission to construct 99 homes and the site is part-built.
But councillors are not yet convinced and have asked for more information.
The company wants Plymouth City Council to discharge all its obligations within a Section 106 agreement which also includes £62,000 towards improvements to Mount Gould Park and £223,000 towards improving secondary school capacity.
It’s request has been supported by planning officers but the council’s planning committee members will have the final say.
Vice chair of the planning committee Cllr Jon Dingle (Lab, St Budeaux) said the committee deferred the application at its meeting on Thursday because it wanted a clearer understanding before making a decision.
He said affordable housing was “a hugely important issue” as there was a “significant shortage” not just in Plymouth but right across the country.
Councillors had a responsibility to do everything they reasonably could to protect and secure affordable housing opportunities for local people, he said.
“You would never want to remove affordable housing obligations unless you were absolutely satisfied that there was no alternative way forward,” he added.
“Affordable housing is too important an issue, and we need to be certain that every possible option has been properly explored before considering removing those obligations.”
More than 6,000 in Plymouth are currently on the housing register waiting for a home.
A viability report with the application by Lipson Developments shows that the scheme, which includes open market homes, is £11.7 million away from being viable with the current 106 asks.
The applicants say that the site’s steeply sloping typography requires “abnormal groundworks, retaining structures and slope stabilisation measures considerably beyond what would be expected on a comparable, typical site.”
It added that a change in fire safety regulations since the original permission was granted had necessitated a redesign of the scheme with cost implications and independent valuation advice on the units completed to date confirming a substantial shortfall against the cost of delivery.
A report to the committee highlights a long history with stalled developments at the location – with numerous developers struggling to implement approved permissions.
The council’s development delivery officer said whilst there was inevitably some uncertainty in any viability exercise and individual assumptions can be debated, they were satisfied that the overall conclusion was “reasonable”.
“I do not consider that relatively modest adjustments to sales values or development costs would materially alter the outcome of the assessment. The key issue is that the development is affected by very substantial site specific costs which significantly reduce the value available to support planning obligations and this is against a backdrop of historically high construction costs.
“My review indicates that there is insufficient value within the scheme to support the affordable housing requirement or the financial contributions secured through the existing Section 106 Agreement”.
Now Playing
Now Playing
Now Playing
Councillors want convincing over viability concerns at troubled homes site
By
Alison Stephenson (Local democracy reporter)
Friday, 30 October 2026
16:44

Unfinished homes in the Lipson development site. Picture: submitted
Wait continues over Plymouth housing plans
Developers will have to wait a bit longer to know if Plymouth planners are prepared to let them drop 44 affordable homes from a scheme at Lipson.
Lipson Developments Ltd claim it is not viable to build the units on former allotment gardens at Prince Maurice Road, where there is planning permission to construct 99 homes and the site is part-built.
But councillors are not yet convinced and have asked for more information.
The company wants Plymouth City Council to discharge all its obligations within a Section 106 agreement which also includes £62,000 towards improvements to Mount Gould Park and £223,000 towards improving secondary school capacity.
It’s request has been supported by planning officers but the council’s planning committee members will have the final say.
Vice chair of the planning committee Cllr Jon Dingle (Lab, St Budeaux) said the committee deferred the application at its meeting on Thursday because it wanted a clearer understanding before making a decision.
He said affordable housing was “a hugely important issue” as there was a “significant shortage” not just in Plymouth but right across the country.
Councillors had a responsibility to do everything they reasonably could to protect and secure affordable housing opportunities for local people, he said.
“You would never want to remove affordable housing obligations unless you were absolutely satisfied that there was no alternative way forward,” he added.
“Affordable housing is too important an issue, and we need to be certain that every possible option has been properly explored before considering removing those obligations.”
More than 6,000 in Plymouth are currently on the housing register waiting for a home.
A viability report with the application by Lipson Developments shows that the scheme, which includes open market homes, is £11.7 million away from being viable with the current 106 asks.
The applicants say that the site’s steeply sloping typography requires “abnormal groundworks, retaining structures and slope stabilisation measures considerably beyond what would be expected on a comparable, typical site.”
It added that a change in fire safety regulations since the original permission was granted had necessitated a redesign of the scheme with cost implications and independent valuation advice on the units completed to date confirming a substantial shortfall against the cost of delivery.
A report to the committee highlights a long history with stalled developments at the location – with numerous developers struggling to implement approved permissions.
The council’s development delivery officer said whilst there was inevitably some uncertainty in any viability exercise and individual assumptions can be debated, they were satisfied that the overall conclusion was “reasonable”.
“I do not consider that relatively modest adjustments to sales values or development costs would materially alter the outcome of the assessment. The key issue is that the development is affected by very substantial site specific costs which significantly reduce the value available to support planning obligations and this is against a backdrop of historically high construction costs.
“My review indicates that there is insufficient value within the scheme to support the affordable housing requirement or the financial contributions secured through the existing Section 106 Agreement”.
Now Playing
More from Radio Exe




Councillors want convincing over viability concerns at troubled homes site
Now Playing
By
Alison Stephenson (Local democracy reporter)
Friday, 30 October 2026
16:44

Unfinished homes in the Lipson development site. Picture: submitted
Wait continues over Plymouth housing plans
Developers will have to wait a bit longer to know if Plymouth planners are prepared to let them drop 44 affordable homes from a scheme at Lipson.
Lipson Developments Ltd claim it is not viable to build the units on former allotment gardens at Prince Maurice Road, where there is planning permission to construct 99 homes and the site is part-built.
But councillors are not yet convinced and have asked for more information.
The company wants Plymouth City Council to discharge all its obligations within a Section 106 agreement which also includes £62,000 towards improvements to Mount Gould Park and £223,000 towards improving secondary school capacity.
It’s request has been supported by planning officers but the council’s planning committee members will have the final say.
Vice chair of the planning committee Cllr Jon Dingle (Lab, St Budeaux) said the committee deferred the application at its meeting on Thursday because it wanted a clearer understanding before making a decision.
He said affordable housing was “a hugely important issue” as there was a “significant shortage” not just in Plymouth but right across the country.
Councillors had a responsibility to do everything they reasonably could to protect and secure affordable housing opportunities for local people, he said.
“You would never want to remove affordable housing obligations unless you were absolutely satisfied that there was no alternative way forward,” he added.
“Affordable housing is too important an issue, and we need to be certain that every possible option has been properly explored before considering removing those obligations.”
More than 6,000 in Plymouth are currently on the housing register waiting for a home.
A viability report with the application by Lipson Developments shows that the scheme, which includes open market homes, is £11.7 million away from being viable with the current 106 asks.
The applicants say that the site’s steeply sloping typography requires “abnormal groundworks, retaining structures and slope stabilisation measures considerably beyond what would be expected on a comparable, typical site.”
It added that a change in fire safety regulations since the original permission was granted had necessitated a redesign of the scheme with cost implications and independent valuation advice on the units completed to date confirming a substantial shortfall against the cost of delivery.
A report to the committee highlights a long history with stalled developments at the location – with numerous developers struggling to implement approved permissions.
The council’s development delivery officer said whilst there was inevitably some uncertainty in any viability exercise and individual assumptions can be debated, they were satisfied that the overall conclusion was “reasonable”.
“I do not consider that relatively modest adjustments to sales values or development costs would materially alter the outcome of the assessment. The key issue is that the development is affected by very substantial site specific costs which significantly reduce the value available to support planning obligations and this is against a backdrop of historically high construction costs.
“My review indicates that there is insufficient value within the scheme to support the affordable housing requirement or the financial contributions secured through the existing Section 106 Agreement”.
Now Playing
Our top picks




